vs
Hale vs Security Boss
Both are premium, made-to-order USA pet doors. Security Boss builds around the security panel and the patio insert. Hale builds around fit, a door sized to your pet and integrated into your home across five install types, with a lifetime frame warranty. Here is where each one is the better buy.
A real Hale Door Model install
The short answer
Which one is right for you?
Nobody lands here to save twenty dollars. You are spending a few hundred, sometimes more than a thousand, once, and trying to get it right. Both brands are premium. The question is which one fits the project in front of you.
Choose Hale if…
You want a permanent, custom-fit door built into your home.
- A precise fit, 11 standard sizes plus custom, sized by width and shoulder height with a 2,247-breed guide
- A door, wall, screen, in-glass, or kennel install, integrated to look original to the home
- A soft flap that a timid, small, or aging pet pushes through easily from day one
- A lower starting price, a lifetime frame warranty, and a friendlier return window
Choose Security Boss if…
You want their security panel, or a removable patio insert.
- Maximum hard security, their 1-inch insulated metal MaxSeal Pro panel and deadbolt-style lock
- A removable, lockable sliding-glass patio insert you can pop out when you move
- The tallest opening on the chart, their "Behemoth" size at 15.75″ × 32″
- A wide commercial menu of guillotine and kennel hardware variants
It comes down to one question: is a maximum-security panel or a slide-out insert the thing you are buying, or is a better-fitting, better-supported permanent door the smarter buy? For most homes, it is the second. The rest of this page shows you why, and where it isn't.
Two premium brands, two different bets
A security panel vs. a custom-fit door
This is the real split. Security Boss optimizes hardest for the lock-off panel and the patio insert. Hale optimizes hardest for a door that becomes part of the house and stays serviceable for decades. Both bets are legitimate. They suit different buyers.
Our philosophy: "fit the pet, fit the house"
A permanent, custom-fit door
A flexible 3/16″ PVC flap with Alnico 5 magnets in a 6063-T5 extruded aluminum frame, built to order in 11 standard sizes or fully custom, sized by your pet's width and shoulder height. We started in 1985 when a Phoenix glazier built the first in-glass pet door from a single customer request.
Security Boss's philosophy: "more secure, better sealed"
A security-panel specialist
Family-owned out of La Crosse, Wisconsin since 2011, with an A+ BBB rating and a genuinely wide catalog. The flagship MaxSeal family leans into the name: a hard lock-off panel and a removable patio insert, hand-built to order in aluminum.
A note on weather. Both are weather-sealed premium doors that just seal differently, aluminum frames, magnetic sealing, double-flap options. Neither of us should claim a certified lab edge. The honest variables are flap count, install quality, your climate, and the right model.
In fairness
The narrow cases where Security Boss wins
A comparison that only flatters one side is not worth reading. Here is where Security Boss is the better buy, plainly, starting with the one they truly own. If one of these is a hard requirement, buy theirs with confidence.
Maximum hard security
They earn the name. MaxSeal Pro adds a 1-inch insulated metal interior security panel and a deadbolt-style lock, and ships with one-way security screws. If hard lock-off is what keeps you up at night, their Pro panel is the stronger answer.
A removable patio insert
The MaxSeal patio panel spring-loads into a slider track with no screws or hardware, then pops out when you move. If a lockable, removable sliding-glass insert is your hard requirement, they deserve the sale.
The tallest opening
Their Pro door and wall lines reach a "Behemoth" size at 15.75″ × 32″, taller than Hale's largest standard Giant at 15.5″ × 27.5″. For a very tall Great Dane or wolfhound that needs maximum off-the-shelf height, they win the raw dimension.
Commercial kennel depth
For glaziers, kennel builders, and commercial buyers, they stock a deep menu of guillotine hardware, insulated, classic, and auto-locking variants, plus architectural drawings and spec sheets. More shelves stocked for the contractor.
On glass specifically, the choice is one word. If "removable" is what decides it, that is Security Boss. If "built-in" is what decides it, Hale's In-Glass Model integrates into the door without eating usable width, and looks like it was always there. Different jobs.
Why Hale wins
Five places Hale comes out ahead
For most homeowners cross-shopping these two, it comes down to these five, starting with the one that prevents the most expensive mistake in the category.
The door fits your pet, not the other way around.
The most expensive mistake here is a hole in the wrong size, and a return will not un-cut it. We publish 11 standard sizes from Small Medium up to Giant, sized by your pet's width, shoulder height, and step-over rise, not just weight, which is what trips people up with deep-chested or low-slung breeds.
On top of that sits a 2,247-breed sizing guide, so you start from your actual dog instead of a generic chart. Security Boss sizes well and their Behemoth beats our Giant on height. But the everyday homeowner trying not to botch a cut gets a clearer, more hand-held path with Hale.
We would rather spend ten minutes getting your size right than process a return.
11 standard sizes + custom
Door · Wall · Screen · In-glass · Kennel
Five install families, integrated to look built-in
Pick your install type and we build for it directly: a door, a wall, a screen, an in-glass panel, or a kennel. Our wall model ships self-framing, pre-wrapped aluminum tunnel, carpet lining, flashing, and a raincap, a clean, weather-sealed permanent install.
Where Security Boss leans on the slide-in patio insert, our in-glass answer is a built-in panel that does not sacrifice doorway width and looks original to the home.
A flap tuned for the timid, small, and aging
A tight seal is a tradeoff: the harder the flap pushes back, the more your pet has to shove. Some Security Boss owners love the heavy-duty feel; others note the dual flaps can stick together for a slow-moving dog, or that stronger magnets meant a few days of training.
Our flexible 3/16″ PVC flap with Alnico 5 magnets is tuned to stay quiet and easy for timid, small, elderly, or mobility-limited pets to push through, while still sealing. If you have a hesitant or aging dog, that day-one usability matters more than a spec sheet suggests.
One owner who has installed hundreds of pet doors called the MaxSeal double-flap the best he had found, then added the honest caveat: pet doors "are not submarine doors." Any flap light enough for a pet to push has sealing limits, ours included. , owner on Reddit
Soft flap · low push-force
Door & Wall, direct pricing
Premium, with a lower floor
Don't let anyone tell you one brand is flatly cheaper. It moves with the install. But on the two installs most people buy, door and wall, Hale starts lower, with custom sizing built into the price instead of charged as an exception.
The cleanest line on the page: covered for life.
Hale backs the frame for life and the flap with a 10-year prorated warranty. Security Boss offers a 6-year limited warranty on many residential products, prorated on a schedule that drops fast, 100% in year one, then down toward 10% by year six. On a product you install permanently, the frame is the part you most want covered forever.
Returns matter too, because this is measurement-sensitive hardware. New, in-box Hale returns get a full refund inside 30 days, less shipping, and a 10% restock fee from 31 to 90 days. Security Boss charges a 16% restock fee inside 30 days, and 26% if they accept a return at 30 to 60 days. For ordinary second thoughts, Hale costs you less to change your mind.
Price: it depends on the install, not the brand
The sticker is only the start
Neither brand is the budget option. The decision is not "which is cheaper," it is "which fits the project." Here is the honest read by install type, then the two numbers the sticker never shows.
| Install type | |
 |
|---|---|---|
| Door-mounted | ✓$216–$699 | MaxSeal $229–$757; Pro $238–$817 |
| Wall-mounted | ✓$269–$796 | MaxSeal $256–$841; Pro $289–$1,128 |
| Screen | $149–$251 | ~$134–$266 |
| In-glass (excl. glass) | $161–$768 | MaxSeal $247–$714; Pro $249–$829 |
| Sliding-glass patio insert | Routed to In-Glass (permanent) | SB Standard $373–$605; MaxSeal $729–$1,103 |
| Kennel | $365–$975 | ~$19 hardware up to $500+ premium |
Direct list prices, the most time-sensitive line on this page. Re-check any sale price before you order. The patio-insert row is apples-to-oranges, Security Boss owns the removable insert outright; Hale routes sliding-glass buyers to a permanent in-glass build.
Two things the sticker won't tell you
Budget for the opening, not just the unit, and know that flaps are a long-term line item on both sides.
A door-mount you do yourself makes the door the main cost. A wall install, cutting through framing, siding, insulation, and weatherproofing, can turn a $500 door into a four-figure project once you pay a contractor. True on either brand.
On either brand, the pet door is a few hundred dollars; the fabricated glass and the glazier are the rest. Security Boss is explicit that they warranty the pet door, not the glass it goes into. The same reality applies to ours.
Neither company sells a buy-it-once product. The good news: both are built to be serviced rather than tossed. Their parts ecosystem is strong, and so is ours, flaps, kits, weatherstripping, tunnel kits, raincaps, and lock parts all stocked.
Lower up front, with one known cost later
Security Boss is priced like a premium door and usually manageable later, until the security panel, the patio track, or a Pro wall climbs past four figures. Hale starts lower on the door and wall projects most people actually buy, with a soft replacement flap you swap on schedule and a frame covered for life.
The cheapest insurance against the priciest mistake, cutting the wrong opening, is getting the size right the first time. That is the part we obsess over.
Side-by-side
The whole picture, on one screen
Everything below is current and verifiable. On the lines most buyers weigh, fit, install breadth, price, warranty, and returns, Hale comes out ahead (✓). Security Boss leads on the security panel, the removable insert, and the tallest opening.
| Comparison point | |
|
|---|---|---|
| Built to order in the USA | Yes, since 1985, Cañon City, CO | Yes, since 2011, La Crosse, WI |
| Moving part | Flexible 3/16″ PVC flap, Alnico 5 magnets | UV-treated vinyl flap, dual-flap & high-wind options |
| Frame | 6063-T5 extruded aluminum | Aluminum |
| Install types | ✓Door, wall, screen, in-glass, kennel | Door, wall, in-glass, French, patio, screen, kennel |
| Sizing | ✓11 standard + custom; by width & shoulder height; 2,247-breed guide | 10 MaxSeal sizes + custom; "Behemoth" 15.75″ × 32″ |
| Tallest standard opening | Giant 15.5″ × 27.5″ | "Behemoth" 15.75″ × 32″ |
| Door price (direct) | ✓$216–$699 | $229–$817 |
| Wall price (direct) | ✓$269–$796 | $256–$1,128 |
| Removable patio insert | Routed to In-Glass (permanent) | Yes, core strength |
| Security lock-off | ¼″ HDPE cover + steel pin lock (most models) | 1″ insulated metal panel (Pro); deadbolt-style lock |
| Frame warranty | ✓Lifetime | 6-year limited, prorated |
| Flap / panel warranty | 10-year prorated flap | Under the 6-year schedule |
| Returns (new, in-box) | ✓Full refund <30 days, less shipping; 10% restock 31–90 days | 16% restock <30 days; 26% if accepted 30–60 days; custom non-returnable |
| Smart / microchip access | None | None |
| Independent review profile | ✓Trustpilot 4.4/5, 482 reviews | Mostly on-site & reseller reviews |
The pattern on the skim: Security Boss takes the security panel, the removable insert, and the tallest opening. Hale takes the fit guidance, the warranty headline, the friendlier returns, and the cleaner permanent install across more of the house.
What Security Boss owners say
The loyalty is real, and so is the friction
We will let their customers speak, including the good, because it is mostly good. A well-built MaxSeal lasts. The recurring friction is the same lesson every time: a premium pet door is a real install, and the fit has to be right before you cut.
On durability, the loyalty is real
My mother's MaxSeal has lasted 10+ years and is still as good as new.
Security Boss owner review
On security, the emotional hook
The sturdy frame, strong magnetic close, and customizable locking panel give me peace of mind at night in the city.
MaxSeal Pro door review
On the wall install, the sharpest honest review
I would buy it again, but the interior hinge protruded into the security-door track, the rivets rubbed enough that I filed them down, no drip flashing was included, and the instructions were not as clear as I expected.
MaxSeal Pro wall review
On finding an installer
Beautiful and well built, but I couldn't find anyone to install it.
Screen door review
On the instructions
I loved my unit, but I wished the instructions were better or had a video.
Security Boss screen review
On the long haul
We've run Security Boss doors for 20 years, with the oldest still in daily use.
Teton Gravity
The takeaway is not that Security Boss is hard to live with, its owners clearly love it. It is that getting the fit and the install path right before you cut is where the whole experience is won or lost. That is exactly the part we obsess over: sizing help, install-type guidance, and a wall model that ships self-framing, pre-wrapped tunnel, carpet, flashing, and raincap included.
Compare by install type
Brand slogans don't install pet doors. Your project does.
The honest breakdown, by the opening you are actually working with.
Already own a Security Boss door?
Switching from a MaxSeal?
No reason to replace a door doing its job
If your MaxSeal is sealing well, your dog uses it comfortably, and it fits your home, keep it. It is a legitimate premium pet door, and there is no upgrade treadmill in this category. Replacing a door that works is just spending money.
Look at Hale when something is changing: a remodel or a switch from a patio insert to a built-in in-glass or wall door, a worn or wrongly-sized opening you want to get right this time, a new, larger, or aging dog, or simply a fresh purchase where you want a lifetime frame warranty and a friendlier return window.
Swapping over? Don't assume it drops in.
The frames and openings differ, so custom sizing works off real numbers, never an assumption. Before you order:
- Measure your pet, width at the shoulders and the height they can comfortably step over
- Measure the existing opening, interior frame, exterior frame, and the rough cutout if exposed
- Note the wall depth, or the door material and thickness
- Note what you have now, door, wall, sliding glass, or patio insert
- Photograph both sides of the current install
This is the step that prevents an expensive second mistake.
FAQ
Questions shoppers ask comparing the two
? Is Hale a good Security Boss alternative?
Yes, for most homeowners installing a permanent pet door into a door, wall, screen, or glass panel. Hale matches Security Boss on premium, USA-made, built-to-order construction, and pulls ahead on sizing guidance, lifetime frame warranty, return flexibility, and a simpler buying path. Security Boss stays the better pick if you specifically want a removable lockable patio insert or their 1-inch metal security panel.
? Is Security Boss MaxSeal a good pet door?
It is. MaxSeal and MaxSeal Pro are well-built, hand-made-to-order aluminum doors with strong sealing, a genuine security-panel story, and owners who have kept them running for 10, 15, even 20 years. We are not here to talk you out of a good product, just to show you where Hale fits a different kind of buyer better.
? Which is better for a sliding glass door, Hale or Security Boss?
It comes down to one word. If you want a removable insert that slides into the track and comes out when you move, Security Boss is the better buy. If you want a permanent, built-in glass solution that does not sacrifice doorway width and looks original to the home, Hale's In-Glass Model is the stronger long-term choice. Both require professional glass installation.
? Which is better for a large or giant dog?
For raw maximum height, Security Boss's "Behemoth" opening (15.75″ × 32″) beats Hale's largest standard Giant size (15.5″ × 27.5″). For overall fit confidence, 11 sizes, custom sizing, a 2,247-breed guide, and a flap that is easy on aging joints, Hale is the more complete large-dog experience. If you have a very tall breed, compare the exact openings side by side.
? Which is more secure, Hale or Security Boss?
For a hard metal lock-off panel, Security Boss's MaxSeal Pro (a 1-inch insulated metal security panel) is the more aggressive design, and we won't claim Hale out-secures it. Hale builds a durable ¼″ HDPE security cover with a steel pin lock into most models. Both are real lock-off systems. For the vast majority of homes, Hale's lock is more than enough; if maximum hard security is your top priority, Security Boss is built for exactly that.
? Does Hale make a removable patio insert?
No, and we would rather be straight than sell you the wrong thing. For sliding glass doors, Hale builds a permanent, built-in In-Glass door, which is the better long-term solution but is not a slide-in-and-remove insert. If a removable patio insert is your hard requirement, Security Boss is the brand for that job.
? Can I replace a Security Boss pet door with a Hale?
Often, yes, especially if you are changing install types, fixing a poorly-sized opening, or remodeling. Because Hale is made to order, start with our sizing guide to match the new door to your pet and your opening before you order, and send us measurements and photos so we can confirm the fit.
? How long does a Hale pet door take to arrive?
Every Hale is built to order, so there is in-house build time before it ships: roughly 3 to 5 business days for door, wall, and frame models, 5 to 7 for screen, in-glass, and custom sizes, and 10 to 12 for kennel models. Replacement parts ship after 1 to 3 business days. Expedited shipping speeds up transit, not the build.
? Is Hale more weatherproof than Security Boss?
Both are built for weather resistance, aluminum frames, magnetic sealing, weatherstripping, and double-flap options. Neither brand should claim certified lab superiority over the other. The real-world result depends on flap count, install type, your climate, and how well the unit is fitted. Match the configuration to your conditions and either brand seals well.
Find the door that fits your pet
For a maximum-security metal panel, a removable patio insert, or the tallest giant-breed opening, Security Boss may well be your best choice. For a permanent, made-to-order door built into your door, wall, screen, or glass, sized precisely to your pet, backed by a lifetime frame warranty, that is Hale. We have been building exactly this, in the USA, since 1985.